Judges´` Incarceration decisions in Mozambique

The need to decolonise the punitive approach to criminal justice

Autores/as

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.51359/2179-7501.2023.261311

Palabras clave:

Mozambique, prisons, judges, criminal justice

Resumen

Over the last decade, Mozambique embarked on a comprehensive reform that aimed at improving the conditions of prisons in the country. Legal reform was accompanied by institutional reform. Prison conditions, however, have not improved at the pace they should have developed. Based on the findings of research conducted on prisons by the organisations Africa Criminal Justice Reform and REFORMAR- Research for Mozambique, over the last ten years, this article aims at drawing the attention of the prison issues from the judges’ incarceration decisions. In fact, while studies of criminal justice reform have traditionally examined the systematic deficiencies of the prison system, a closer look at the role of judges in the context of prison provides practical understandings, especially where there are substantive non-conformities with the legal framework in place. Solutions are, furthermore, threefold: the use of legal remedies by victims of judicial decisions and the civil liability of the state for illegal detention and the overall decolonisation of the state approach to criminal justice by all actors of the state administration.



Citas

BALTAZAR, R. (1977). “Tribunais Populares. A Justiça Nas Mãos Do Povo,” Revista Tempo. Maputo.

SANTOS DE SOUSA, B. & TRINDADE, C. (2003). Conflito e Transformação Social: Uma Paissagem das Justiças em Moçambique. Oporto, Afrontamento.

ENES, A. (1947). Moçambique, Fourth Edition. Lisboa: Imprensa Nacional.

LORIZZO, T. (2012). Prison reform in Mozambique fails to touch the ground. Assessing the

experience of pre-trial detainees in Maputo. South Africa Crime Quarterly, (42), 29-38.

LORIZZO, T. (2022). Non-state forms of conflict resolution applied to criminal justice: Opportunities for improving criminal justice. The case of community courts in Mozambique. Thesis for the PhD. University of Cape Town. South Africa.

LORIZZO, T. PETROVIC, V. & MUNTINGH, L. (2020). Alternatives to Imprisonment in Mozambique. The implementation of community service orders. Africa Criminal Justice Reform. Consulted on 12 January 2024, available at: https://reformar.co.mz/publicacoes/tsu-moz-english.pdf/view.

MARTINEZ, E. S. (2008). O Trabalho Forçado Na Legislação Colonial Portuguesa - O Caso de Moçambique (1899-1926). Tese de Mestrado. Universidade de Lisboa. Portugal.

ORDEM DOS ADVOGADOS DE MOÇAMBIQUE (2019). Relatório dos Direitos Humanos 2017. Maputo

Procuradoria-Geral da Republica (2018) Children in conflict with the law. Looking for a strategy of protection. Maputo. Consulted on 12 January 2024, available at: https://reformar.co.mz/publicacoes/criancas-em-conflito-pdf.

REFORMAR. (2020). Carta Aberta Sobre o Impacto Do Estado de Emergência No Sector de Justiça Criminal. Consulted on 12 January 2024, available at: https://reformar.co.mz/publicacoes/carta-aberta-impacto-estado-de-emergencia-1.pdf/view

REFORMAR. (2021). Pretrial Detention and Summary Proceedings in Mozambique - A look at the situation of children and minors in Tete. Maputo.

RODRIGUES, L.F. (1963) Contribuição Para o Estudo Do Sistema Prisional No Ultramar. Instituto Superior de Ciências Sociais e Política Ultramarina: Universidade Técnica de Lisboa. Portugal.

VAN ZYL SMIT, D. and JIMADA, Z. (2020). Life imprisonment worldwide revisited. Centre for Research and Education in Security, Prisons and Forensic Psychiatry.

Publicado

2024-04-02

Número

Sección

DOSSIÊ Desenvolvimento local, participação e direitos das minorias. Perspectivas do Sul global